I’ve Been Visiting the U.S. Virgin Islands for Years—This Is the Island Everyone Overlooks

No matter how many times I visit the U.S. Virgin Islands, St. Croix is the one that keeps pulling me back. My family lives on the island, which brings me back at least a couple of times each year, but it’s not the only reason I return. St. Croix is a place where lush rainforests, uncrowded beaches, and everyday local life coexist in a way that feels increasingly rare in the Caribbean.

I’ve visited all of the U.S. Virgin Islands, and they are all great in their own ways. St. Croix definitely has a more local feel, though. Despite being the largest, St. Croix remains the least talked about (and that’s part of its appeal to me). But there are still plenty of amazing things to experience when you visit. Here are some of my personal favorite things to see and do if you visit one of the best islands in the Caribbean. 

As a part of the Sandy Point National Wildlife Refuge, this unspoiled coastline is my favorite beach on St. Croix. It’s closed to the public from mid-April through August to protect nesting sea turtles, but if your trip is timed right, it’s absolutely worth the visit. The beach is picture-perfect and undeveloped, so be sure to bring everything you need, as there aren’t any concessions or stores within the refuge. 

Visible from the mainland, but accessible only by boat, Buck Island is an uninhabited national monument with one of the best snorkeling experiences in the U.S. Virgin Islands. You can book a tour with Big Beard’s Adventure Tours or Caribbean Sea Adventures to explore the Buck Island Reef, an underwater snorkeling trail just off the shore. Expect vibrant coral, abundant marine life, and a secluded beach with no facilities. Make sure you pack food, water, and everything you’ll need for the day. 

This popular beach sits right along the roadside with local spots nearby like The Landing and Off the Wall, making it easy to grab food and drinks during your day at the beach. Cane Bay is especially loved by divers, as there’s a huge drop-off just offshore that descends thousands of feet. Sweet Bottom Dive Center is conveniently located nearby and leads guided shore dives at one of the Caribbean’s most unique dive sites. 

If you’re hoping to get out and enjoy some on-the-water action, this is a great beach to check out. West End Watersports rents jet skis, but if you want to enjoy the water at a slower pace, they also have paddleboards and kayaks available. Rhythms is a lively beach bar that is right there on site also, giving you everything you need all in one spot. 

Although you’ll feel like you’re in another world, St. Croix is a U.S. territory, and it’s home to one of the country’s most scenic landmarks. Point Udall marks the easternmost point of the United States and that’s where you’ll find the Millennium Monument. The large sundial is surrounded by spectacular panoramic views. 

What’s better than riding horses through a lush island rainforest and taking a dip in the sparkling Caribbean waters? Doing that and helping out a great cause at the same time. Cruzan Cowgirls is a nonprofit organization dedicated to rescuing and rehabilitating horses. The proceeds from the tours help fund the organization’s mission, making this the most exciting way to give back. 

Whether you’re casting a line from shore or heading offshore to deeper water, one thing is certain—St. Croix is an excellent fishing location. I end up with a line in the water every time I go, and I often just fish from shore with my family. I’ve also gone out to deeper waters with Lioness Sportfishing and had an awesome time. They offer shore-based tours, as well as inshore and offshore fishing expeditions. 

St. Croix is home to The Nature Conservancy’s Virgin Islands Coral Innovation Hub. This coral laboratory is located at Estate Little Princess—a former sugar and rum plantation. It’s now a place where marine biologists propagate coral used to restore damaged reefs. It’s a fascinating process, and they welcome visitors to come out for free tours on Tuesdays at 2 p.m. and Thursdays at 10 a.m. I’ve really enjoyed visiting, and I feel it is a unique way to see coral up close and personal without even getting wet.     

The Annaly Bay Tide Pools consist of some striking rock formations and this geological wonder offers a truly surreal swimming experience. However, getting there is part of the fun as well. I’ve hiked there from a trail that starts by Carambola Beach Resort, but I’ve also gone off-roading with my friend through wooded, winding trails. It is such an exciting ride, but I wouldn’t try to drive that path on my own. Tan Tan Tours offers that same rugged experience, though. 

The Christiansted boardwalk is situated alongside the water and this area is where you’ll find some really cute, local shops. Sonya’s Fine Island Jewelry is one of my personal favorites, and if you’re looking for a nice souvenir to take home, go here. Every Crucian you meet will likely be wearing one of the island’s signature hook bracelets, and this is where you can get your own. The Mitchell Larsen Studio is another spot I love that has local glass art, but if you’re looking for more traditional souvenirs like t-shirts, check out Purple Papaya. 

This laid-back restaurant will make you feel like you’re hanging out in your cool best friend’s backyard, complete with some of the best BBQ and cocktails on St. Croix. Even when I’ve been away for months, the bartender Eddie always has my favorite drink (a Voodoo) waiting on the bar by the time I walk up from the car. He makes it the kind of place where everyone instantly feels welcome and like a regular. If you time your visit right, you can also enjoy some great live music at Blues BBQ. 

Hidden away in the middle of the rainforest is a unique local hangout that has beer-drinking pigs. After buying one of the resident pigs a non-alcoholic beer, head to the bar for your own drink. The signature beverage at Domino Club is the popular Mamawanna. Nobody knows the exact recipe of this homemade favorite, but it’s rum infused with a secret recipe of herbs, spices, and honey. Their Johnny Cakes are really tasty, too. They don’t accept credit cards there, but they will take Venmo if you don’t have cash.

My family likes going here for special occasions, but Duggan’s Reef is a good choice anytime—especially if you want epic oceanfront views. Located right along the water’s edge, the restaurant is known for excellent seafood and steaks. Their lobster and lobster bisque are my favorite items there (it’s true culinary perfection). This is a local spot you’ll want to try, but just make sure you make reservations in advance. 

This casual spot may be known for its burgers, but my go-to at Cheeseburger in Paradise is the ooey-gooey artichoke and spinach dip. It is so good! If you go and Ginger is behind the bar, order a Lime in da Coconut. This drink is similar to a pina colada, but with a lime twist. I’m not sure what else she puts in hers, but I think she makes the best ones on the island. 

This island paradise knows how to throw a party, and depending on when you go, you may be able to join in the fun. Many of St. Croix’s celebrations feature the iconic Moko Jumbies. These stilt walkers dress in colorful costumes and tower above the crowds as they dance through the streets. They show up at most events, and no matter how many times I see them, I never cease to be amazed by their eccentric dance moves.